Best Picture : The Departed - Scorsese finally got his Oscar with this remake of the Chinese film Infernal Affairs. The cast is stellar and the unfolding of the story quite gripping. I wouldn't have put it as best picture, but it is a good film nonetheless.
Biggest Box Office : Pirates of the Caribbean Dead Man's Chest - The worst (arguably) Pirates movie drew huge crowds with this film that finely fits the definition of underwhelming. Where the first film was surprising, engaging and smart, this film is overblown, plodding and dim.